A Hyundai spokesman said the automaker is unhappy that the jury did not award damages to Hyundai and is “reviewing and looking at all accessible options going ahead.”
He said Hyundai shipped evidence that the dealership submitted fraudulent remember replacement claims.
“Such a plan not only harms Hyundai but also affects our prospects and the West Palm Community,” the spokesman said in a assertion. “We are delighted that the jury uncovered that two of the defendants dedicated the warranted fraud we introduced.”
Napleton countersued Hyundai in August 2021, accusing the automaker of unfair motor vehicle allocation. The jury dominated against Napleton in relation to individuals promises.
“The jury identified and agreed that Hyundai’s allocation of cars to West Palm Seaside Hyundai was good less than all the situation and uncovered in Hyundai’s favor on all counts,” the Hyundai spokesman explained.
Guarantee fraud?
From 2015 by 2019, Hyundai recalled particular Sonata, Santa Fe Activity, Tucson and Veloster versions for potential engine failure and prolonged its powertrain warranty protection over and above the first car customer.
In Hyundai’s 2020 lawsuit, the automaker claimed that given that at the very least 2016, defendants acquired sure Sonata and Santa Fe vehicles from auctions and filed fraudulent warranty claims on such motor vehicles to Hyundai. Hyundai would then reimburse them for the maintenance or would repurchase the motor vehicle. In 2017, the alleged scheme created about $180,000 in revenue for Napleton’s West Palm Beach front dealership.
The countersuit by Napleton’s West Palm Beach Hyundai shop accused Hyundai of fraud and violations of Florida dealership regulation. Napleton said that Hyundai’s Accelerate dealership impression plan, incentive programs and Genesis auto distribution necessities violated Florida law and accused Hyundai of price tag discrimination.
The countersuit also claimed Hyundai initially sued Napleton Automotive to divert consideration from its have engine failure “debacle” and “to harass West Palm, spoil its reputation and destruction its small business. Hyundai is on a mission to get absent all of the Napleton organization’s Hyundai shops affiliated with West Palm.” Hyundai at the time called individuals counterclaims “frivolous.”
The team also claimed Hyundai based mostly vendor margins on revenue performance targets and facility needs and gave inconsistent per-auto incentives to Hyundai sellers during Florida.
Melissa Load, Miranda Dunlap and Paige Hodder contributed to this report.
